And it’s something that no other D1 wrestler may ever do again. Yes, it’s true, Carter Starocci is the first D1 wrestler in history to win five titles. But, does that make him the best ever?

Subscribe Login Register Log out My Profile Subscriber Services Search PGe NEWSLETTERS PG STORE ARCHIVES OBITUARIES JOBS PUBLIC NOTICES CLASSIFIEDS EVENTS PETS CONTACT US ADVERTISING CAREER ...

Two of college wrestling’s elite talents — Carter Starocci and ... as the greatest amateur wrestler of all time. It seems that the sport’s heightened profile has also brought back a long ...

"Not only is Starocci the best wrestler in 2025. Carter would beat Hendrickson 10 out of 10 times. Not even close," one user wrote. "But starocci still has a higher win bonus percentage.

Henckel isn’t the only wrestler in the family, though—his sister ... At the next level, Henckel looks most ready to compete at 174 lbs or 184 lbs with Carter Starocci leaving. Henckel is also adept at ...

Maybe. A testament to Carter Starocci’s work ethic and desire to win? Certainly. The group departed dinner bound for the Millcreek home of Ian Malesiewski, a Prep wrestler left paralyzed after ...

has just been named the most outstanding wrestler at the NCAA Championships. Penn State announced that Carter Starocci, the first-ever five-time national champion in NCAA history, was also named ...

For 10 minutes straight Saturday night, Penn State wrestler Carter Starocci downplayed his history-making fifth NCAA title the way an NBA all-star might dismiss winning a pickup game. Minutes ...