The Mother’s Day aisle at the supermarket glows the same shade of blush-pink every year. Stacks of scented candles, glossy ...

The clothing section presents a fashion timeline that spans decades, from vintage dresses that could have graced a Mad Men set to barely-worn contemporary pieces still bearing their original tags.

While tourists flock to Florida’s beaches and theme parks, savvy locals know the real magic happens in places like this, where $26 can fill an entire shopping cart with goodies that would cost ...