As Netflix confirmed the official cast list for season 2 in May 2024, Deadline reported that Percy Hynes White, Jamie McShane and Naomi J Ogawa would not be back as series regulars. The outlet added that only McShane is slated to reprise his role as Sheriff Donovan Galpin as a guest star to wrap up his character's storyline.

Along with Gaga’s performance, Netflix released the opening minutes of season two, with Wednesday locked in a serial killer’s (Haley Joel Osment) basement, recounting how she ended up there and explaining that the killer thinks she is his next victim.