Following the death of Elsa on the trail, John and his remaining family decided to settle in ... to Claire’s scorn by shooting several members of the wagon train, including Mary Abel, Claire ...

Beth will do whatever it takes to protect her family and has made a sworn enemy of her adopted brother, Jamie. Rip, though he married into the family, was a wayward boy whom John took under his wing.

The Dutton family tree is pretty complicated ... Yellowstone's finale made the "take back" pretty clear, so we're definitely done counting. As it stands now, the inconsistencies can be explained ...