‘South Park’ Solves The Columbus Day Debate By Letting Randy Marsh Play His Very Stupid Victim Card Andrew Roberts Entertainment Writer September 28, 2017 ...

Now, Shelly Marsh has never been the kindest South Park resident; she was initially conceived as an older sister who tortured Stan because That’s What Older Siblings Do.

In South Park’s version, the singer is not actually a teenage girl, but Randy Marsh, a middle-age man pretending to be a pop star.