Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar haven’t talked in many summers. The actress, 46, revealed that she has not kept in touch with her “I Know What You Did Last Summer” co-star, 48, since starring in the 1997 slasher together.

Hewitt and Prinze Jr. reprise their role as Julie James and Ray Bronson, respectively, in the latest sequel that hit theaters on Friday. Though the “Cruel Intentions” star’s character, Helen Shivers, was killed off in the first film, she shows up for a quick cameo via a dream sequence.