Advice How to Respond (Politely) to a Negative Peer Review Dos and don’ts for defending your scholarly writing from a harsh critique. By Rebecca Colesworthy January 15, 2025 James Yang for The ...

Peer-to-peer feedback has increased in recent years, in part due to 360-degree review programs where an individual receives a full sphere of assessment from managers, direct reports and peers.

We might secretly dream of the manuscript that comes back with “Perfect! We’ll print it. Don’t change a thing.” But most mortals instead face rejection at worst and extended critique at best. It’s ...

Ruth Weintraub, Peer disagreement and counter-examples, Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition, Vol. 177, No. 7 (July 2020), pp. 1773-1790 ...

So this evening I re-read my work on collaboration and critique. In the spirit of my research, I’m remembering mistakes are a great opportunity to try again. I’m holding off on our first peer ...