As one viewer wrote, “It’s good ice cream (some flavors), but it sure ain’t $21.99 good.” “It’s overpriced but Cold Stone is some top-tier ice cream that you can get,” another echoed.

Cold Stone Creamery has over 20 combinations of ice cream and mix-ins called Signature Creations. The Founder's Favorite was too sweet for me even though I liked the brownies. I loved the Mud Pie ...

Cold Stone Creamery’s website doesn’t specifically confirm if it charges extra for Reese’s. However, they do charge more for their ice cream and certain toppings than other chains.