That moment happens with remarkable frequency at Bird in Hand Bakeshop, a charming Amish bakery nestled in the heart of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. The red-roofed building sits unassumingly along ...

Available in varieties like the classic salt and butter, cinnamon sugar for sweet-leaning palates, garlic and herb for savory enthusiasts, sour cream and onion (an Amish favorite), and Parmesan cheese ...