Paradise Blue Tieks Shoe, $265, Tieks 7. Nail Polish A lot of brides opt for subtle nail polish like light pink or nude, but if you want to do something a little more fun, blue is your best bet.

Amanda, a marketing director from Ellicott City, and Matt, a project manager from Catonsville, met at a mutual friend’s house. Three years after a first date at Nick’s Fish House in Baltimore, Matt ...