Butterscotch Pudding – In the Harry Potter books, the three key ingredients in butterbeer are butterscotch, sugar and water. This pudding gives our cookies that all-important butterscotch flavor.

While your cookies bake, it’s time to make your caramel and icing. I’m not great at making homemade caramel and @tabbycakes1313 doesn’t share their recipe, so I just went the store-bought route.

Fans who want something more rich should try Keebler’s Limited-Edition Harry Potter Butterbeer Fudge Stripes Cookies, which are definitely sweeter than the crackers. And if you’re looking for ...

Keebler launches Harry Potter Butterbeer Fudge Stripes in a magical collaboration with Warner Bros. Experience butterbeer flavor: cream soda and butterscotch on limited-edition cookies with iconic ...

Keebler limited-edition Harry Potter Butterbeer fudge stripes cookies are available at nationwide retailers for a suggested retail price of $4.80.

Everyone seems to love Harry Potter. The novels remain popular. If you still have cable, the movies are as easy to find playing as The Godfather or James Bond once was. While not new by any means ...