Jeff Buckley was so ashamed to be in PEOPLE's '50 Most Beautiful' he bought all the copies he could to hide it. Story by Maureen Lee Lenker • 10h. T he new documentary "It's Never Over, ...

Cruise was 34 — and still married to Nicole Kidman — when he graced PEOPLE's 50 Most Beautiful cover with Toni Braxton (her second appearance) and Drew Barrymore. Leonardo DiCaprio, 1998.

A new documentary reveals that singer Jeff Buckley tried to buy as many copies of PEOPLE's '50 Most Beautiful' issue as he could to prevent fans from seeing him in it.

The new documentary "It's Never Over, Jeff Buckley," which just premiered at Sundance, explores the '90s singer-songwriter's struggle with fame.