Everlane’s The Air Long-Sleeve Tee is the best long-sleeved T-shirt for women, according to our style writer, who also found fitted, seamless, and ribbed styles.

If a long sleeve feels too formal or stiff, a quick cuff or a messy push-up to the elbow gives it a whole new energy—way more relaxed and lived-in.

The best men’s long-sleeved T-shirt overall is Gildan’s 2400. Our wardrobe-basics writer interviewed more than ten stylish people and tested their recommendations herself.