Häagen-Dazs is best. It's dense white ice cream with a big dairy flavor, a full mint flavor, and lots of crunchy dark-chocolate pieces.

The Peanuts for Chocolate ice cream was seemingly made for fans of peanut ... so it didn't quite achieve the cookies-and-creme flavor advertised on the box. That wasn't a dealbreaker, though.

Notably, the packaging on Wegmans' and Costco's ice-cream bars advertised desserts with a "chocolate-flavored coating," but the 365 box said its dessert was "dipped in organic chocolate." ...