Somehow, it's already October 31st, and you've realized that you don't have a costume or spooky manicure ... wear this season—just add a cat ear headband and tail. And your next stop?

A cat costume has so many details that you can make your own. You can play around with the whiskers, tail, ears, and don't even get me started on the cool eye makeup you can do. I mean ...

"There's still pink in my ears," Earle tells PEOPLE at the 2024 CFDA Awards when discussing her Cheshire Cat Halloween costume that involved full body paint Skyler Caruso is a Writer and Reporter ...