Aubrey Plaza and Jeff Baena were together for over a decade ahead of his death in 2025. The pair started dating in 2011 but never confirmed exactly when they met or when their love story began.

per a 2022 GQ profile—they began dating in 2011. “I have worked with Jeff on all of his movies,” Plaza said in a 2017 interview with SIFFcast about what called to her about The Little Hours.